Skip to content

The Ground Truth

November 25, 2006

The Lancaster District churches of Lancaster Mennonite Conference are sponsoring an important event on Sunday evening at 7 pm. The Ground Truth is a film that features the voices of soldiers who have served in Iraq. I have previewed the film and would agree with the critics that it is riveting and intensely provocative. Out of their own experiences on the frontlines, the soldiers speak an undeniable truth about the human cost of war.

So why is a group of peace churches sponsoring this event? I believe this event at James St. Mennonite Church represents an attempt to bear witness to our theology of peace, while at the same time responding to those who have served in the military with compassion. The witness would be that it is not only innocent civilians who are the casualties of war. Just as we would advocate against the tendency to de-humanize “the enemy” we are seeking to be consistent with this ethic and not de-humanize those who for whatever reason have served in the military.

I believe the film challenges us to consider what it means as Christians to have a consistent ethic of life. To be pro-life covers a whole range of issues from the womb to the tomb. To espouse family values means we will also take into consideration the impact of our international policies and military campaigns on the lives of families in the countries of occupation.

As Christians in the Anabaptist tradition, we seek to apply the life and teachings of Jesus to real life. We are committed to the belief that Jesus’ words and actions are relevant to the real and complex issues of our day. So to be a follower of Jesus means that we will attempt to follow his teachings and example. So we don’t write off the Sermon on the Mount as impractical in today’s world. Jesus’ call to love our enemies and do good to those who persecute us means that our calling as Christians will place us in some real tensions with the systems and powers of the world. Jesus’ life and teachings are relevant to the real issues of terrorism, sectarian violence, and insurgent attacks.

Yet, we do not view those who have sacrificed much—soldiers and other military personnel—as the enemy. As Christians in the peace tradition, I think we experience a real ambivalence when it comes to honoring veterans. We recognize the personal sacrifice and yet do not support the policies and methods of war. We reserve our allegiance for the Kingdom of God, yet we live as citizens of a nation-state which looks to military might as a primary guarantor of the American way of life. So what do we do with those who have left home and family to put their lives in places of dangers to do what their nation’s government says is right? What do we do with their willingness to lay down their lives? I believe this film is one attempt to listen to their voices. I believe the truth they speak of out of their experience should only increase our commitment to be peacemakers in a world gone mad with violence.

If we are going to be peacemakers, we must be committed to truth-telling. If Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life, we must take seriously his words that call us to love of enemy and the way of the cross. This is not just an elective part of the Christian Way, it is the essential core curriculum for those who are seeking first the Kingdom of God. The Christendom model of Christianity is bankrupt. Let’s take the cross off our sword and shields (and the contemporary munitions). Let us stop killing in the name of Jesus. Let’s take ourselves off the white horse bringing about the apocalypse through our righteous violence against the axis of evil. That narrative must be tested with Scripture and named for what it is–a counterfeit of the Christian understanding of sin and the human condition.

In previous posts I have acknowledged that I don’t expect the kingdoms of this world to appropriate the teachings of Jesus. But as a Church, let us at least recognize that we are called to be a counter-community—salt and light. Nevertheless, as we bear witness to a peaceable kingdom, we will engage the kingdoms of this world in a spirit of love and compassion. And we do not just remain quiet when our silence represents a complicity with failed policies and short-sighted doctrines of war. We renew our commitment to be ambassadors of a consistent pro-life ethic.

Keith Olberman is one voice who is raising questions about the way we read current events and history. Whether or not you agree with his tone, I believe the questions he raises are legitimate. The lessons of Vietnam were costly. Let us not reframe that tragic war in a way that blinds us from seeing the truth of the Iraq war.


2 Comments leave one →
  1. Anonymous permalink
    December 1, 2006 7:37 pm

    Thank you for this post on your blog. I haven’t read the others, yet.
    I am a Mennonite Christian in Northeast Ohio. But I wasn’t born into the Mennonite church. I was raised in the Roman Catholic church and my husband was a Penticostal Christian. He wasin the Army and was in the first Gulf War in 1990. He became a Conscientious Objector then and since then we have tried to faithfully serve Christ according to the legacy He left us with.
    When we were part of the military I found conflict with those who spoke of peace. I didn’t get what they were saying. I never totally bought into the military but at the same time didn’t buy into peace either. God changed that for me (and my husband) with the birth of our firstborn.
    Now I’m on the other side. I feel the military life is so far removed from who I am, yet I struggle because I want to understand them. Heck, I used to be one of them, but I have such a hard time, especially in my judgement of those who are in the military.
    Even worse, I struggle in judgement of those in our Mennonite church that do nothing to remind eachother of the history of non-resistance within our own religion.
    For almost 16 years now, I’ve tried to find a way to make the two meet. To be loyal to who I am now and to remember who I was that made me who I am now. But it is hard.
    My point being that in this blog entry you’ve provided us with, you have said some very true things and I support you in your thoughts.
    But how do we combine both communities without clash? I need to know. I’m sure I’m not the only one.
    Thank you!
    God be with you.
    Yvette Coil

  2. Brian Miller permalink
    December 6, 2006 1:54 am

    Thanks for your visit. I’m glad this post was helpful in some way.

    Grace and peace,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: